Nintendo is not a credible source for defining the uber tier. It disallowed Mew and its brethern in the Emerald tour where Mewtwo, Rayquaza and other madmen were allowed. In the Battle Tower, Lati twins are allowed while Celebi and Jirachi are banned.

All you did was tell about one whole tournament that wasn't even in optimal setting (simulators > real battles for playtesting, simply because of the lack of limits by time), and along with stating his weaknesses, declaring it uber. In addition, you were infracted because tier discussion back then was a taboo that always called the same aforementioned crowd foreward that didn't know what they were doing and still present their dumb arguments without any competitive experience whatsoever.

For your "slow" comment, chaos already addressed that, but you decided to ignore it. I guess you don't have an answer.

"Slow to change is not necessarily a bad thing. We try to keep the metagame stable and introduce changes in a way that are manageable. People are not forced to play by our rules; if they want to do whatever, then who cares?"

Hey, as long as you talk shit about Smogon behind our back, you can expect someone to stand up for it. That's the way the world works.